Ask within a week of the customer getting a result, ask specific questions rather than for a testimonial, and use their exact words including the awkward ones. A quote that mentions a hesitation is more persuasive than one that does not, because it reads like a person rather than a marketing department.
The timing and the question do almost all of the work here.
When to ask
There is a window, and it is narrower than most people assume. Ask right after the customer experiences the result they hired you for: the launch went well, the problem stopped, the thing arrived early.
Too early and they have nothing to say. Too late and the feeling has faded into normality, which produces the flat, generic praise that convinces nobody.
Support conversations that end well are the best trigger available, and they are usually invisible to whoever is responsible for marketing.
Never ask for a testimonial
The word itself causes the problem. Asking for a testimonial makes people write in advertising voice, which is exactly the voice a reader discounts.
Ask questions instead and assemble the answer yourself, with their approval. Four questions get you everything you need.
- What were you trying to do before you found us
- What nearly stopped you from going ahead
- What is different now, as specifically as you can put it
- Who would you tell about this, and what would you say
Why the hesitation question matters most
The second question is the one that produces usable material, because the hesitation your customer had is the hesitation your next reader is having right now.
A quote that says the price seemed high until the first month, or that they doubted it would work for a business their size, answers an objection in the voice of someone who had it. No sentence you write yourself can do that.
It also makes the rest of the testimonial credible. Unbroken praise reads as selected; praise that mentions a real reservation reads as reported.
Make it easy to say yes
Every step you add loses people. Offer to do the writing: take their answers, draft the quote, send it back and ask them to change anything that does not sound like them.
Tell them exactly where it will appear and give them the choice of how they are credited. Full name and company is strongest; first name and role is fine; anonymous is nearly worthless and worth saying so politely.
A photo and a link to their site raise believability more than a longer quote does.
What never to do
Do not write testimonials and attribute them to real people, even with permission, without them approving the words. Do not use stock photos next to real quotes. Do not invent customers, which is fabrication rather than marketing and is usually discovered.
Do not offer payment for a positive review, which breaks the rules of every review platform and, in many places, consumer protection law.
And do not edit a quote into saying something the customer did not mean. Tightening is fine; changing the claim is not.
Where to put them
Next to the decision, not on a page of their own. A testimonials page is read by almost nobody; a relevant quote beside the pricing table or the signup button is read by everyone who gets that far.
Match the quote to the moment. Doubts about price go next to the price. Doubts about difficulty go next to the setup instructions. That placement is worth more than the number of quotes you have.
Common questions
- When should I ask for a testimonial?
- Within about a week of the customer getting the result they hired you for. Too early and they have nothing to say; too late and the feeling has faded into normality, which produces flat generic praise.
- What questions produce a good testimonial?
- Never ask for a testimonial, which makes people write in advertising voice. Ask what they were trying to do, what nearly stopped them, what is different now, and who they would tell. Then assemble the quote and get it approved.
- Should a testimonial mention a negative?
- Yes. The hesitation your customer had is the hesitation your reader has right now, and a quote that names a real reservation reads as reported rather than selected.
Keep reading